School’s Not Cool
By Erin Crisp
We have made a new friend, Paul, from Kenya. He eats with us frequently and shares many stories of his country and home. He has already become such a blessing to our family- enlarging our hearts and opening our eyes to a world beyond our own trivial worries.
Last night he was sharing about school in Kenya. Students have to pay for uniforms, books and school fees to attend school. It is a great privilege to attend school. Children cry if they have to stay home from school for any reason and walk many miles sometimes to get an education.
I shared that overall, the perspective of US school children is disappointingly different. Most don’t want to go to school. Teenagers work hard to skip school and many drop out as soon as they are old enough in favor of going their own way.
He was not surprised, just shook his head and said wisely, as he often seems to do, “They do not understand that ‘I am because we are, and we are because I am. (from Desmund Tutu I think he said)’” He went on to explain that in Kenya, children know and understand that their entire existence is dependent on the “we” and the fate of the “we” is dependent on the responsibility (or lack thereof) of the individual. So if I am successful in school, I can help my whole family and whole community. If I squander my chances, I may indirectly or directly cause the death of my family members, friends and community because I become a burden to them, a mouth to feed that can not contribute as effectively as one who pursues his opportunities- whatever they may be- farming, education, etc.
So, short of exposing our children to the travesites of poverty and death, how do our children learn a sense of “we.” How do they come to the important realization that their actions, even as young adolescents, will have far reaching effects for their children, their husbands and wives and even their grandchildren? From teaching this age for a few years, I would assert that they have little to NO understanding of cause and effect that transcends their own lives. Psychologists say this is a normal phase of their development- that adolescents are trapped in a “me” world that is healthy and normal until they move onto the next phase of their development. But is that entirely true? It may help us understand them but should we let them languish there? What can we do to broaden their perspectives? And in so doing broaden our own as adults.
I am because we are, and we are because I am.
This post originally appeared at Erin’s blog Five Crisps: One Mama’s Musings on Her Three Boys and Life.
Tags: Desmond Tutu, Erin Crisp, Kenya, school

July 31st, 2009 at 1:45 pm
Thanks for posting that. Our educational is drowning. I’m at a loss to even propose how to fix it. We may end up having to deconstruct the whole thing and start from scratch. Maybe your friend Paul, and others like him, have some good advice on how to do this?
July 31st, 2009 at 4:37 pm
When I was a teenager I often did the weekly grocery shopping for my family. My mom was working the night shift at the time (and really not coping very well with it), and my Dad appreciated the help with what could be a time-consuming chore. It wasn’t a life or death duty or anything, but I was very aware that our family operated as a unit.
Too often, I think that young people aren’t allowed to grow up and assume (at least some) adult responsibilities. I’m not saying that someone who is 16 (or 12, or 10, or 5) should be expected to act like an adult every minute of the day, but I do think there’s something to be said for expecting every member of a family to contribute to the well-being of the household in some way.
I think this is one of the reasons why a lot of teenagers are so disinterested in school – too often, schools infantilize students. If I was going to have kids, I’d probably homeschool them if it was at all possible.
July 31st, 2009 at 10:48 pm
I agree with Lydia and I am a public school teacher. Sigh. It’s really sad, but as much as I love my school (where I teach is also my alma mater), my husband and I do agree we want to home-school our kids.