Can we have some dialogue, please?
This is my first post here, and I’m struggling with it, so bear with me.
At school (I am just finishing my first year of college), gender roles, their cultural cues, and their implications societally and globally have sparked my interest this year (coming up in classes like International Politics, Anthropology, and Psychology). They interest me probably first because I don’t understand them, and second because they play a huge role in our international and domestic political systems, local cultures, and individual lives (besides churches, families, etc).
The thing is, I’m not hearing much from the church on these topics, and what I do hear seems to be mostly (I’m trying not to exaggerate) hatred and bigotry. I think it is long past time for an honest conversation to take place, but three things seem to inhibit that:
-our desire to be politically correct
-finding the topics removed from real life or irrelevant
-an unwillingness to be open
Ok, so my question for all of you is this, and please read the Newsweek article if you can before responding (unless you’re like an expert, which you may well be). Not that Newsweek makes you an expert, but then we’ll have a little common ground in our (my) limited knowledge.
What makes gender? What, essentially, is gendered, sans culture, environment, parentage, and societal expectations? Are there any innate differences beyond anatomy separating the sexes?
750,000-3 million Americans (less than 1%, but a huge number) “feel there is a disconnect between the sex they were assigned at birth and the way they see or express themselves.” How does this happen? How is it explained? One transgendered person Newsweek references is only six years old.
Furthermore, in the Olympics during the 1960s, “would-be female Olympians were required to undergo gender-screening tests. Essentially, that meant baring all before a panel of doctors who could verify that an athlete had girl parts. That method was soon scrapped in favor of a genetic test. Btu that quickly led to confusion over a handful of genetic disorders that give typical-looking women chromosomes other than the usual XX. Finally the Int’l Olympic Committee ditched the mandatory lab-based screening, too. ‘We found there is no scientifically sound lab-based technique that can differentiate between man and woman,’ sas Arne Ljungqvist, chair of the IOC’s medical commission.”
I don’t know how to pray for thes issues; I don’t know how to relevantly, practically love people involved in them; I don’t know what the church’s response should look like (other than different from what it is now); I don’t know how to follow Jesus through these issues when I’m so overwhelmed and confused and hear primarily a mute or hateful church. Let alone bestiality.

